Tracking down valuable secrets across the frontier in Red Dead Redemption 2 offers players one of the most lucrative ways to fund camp upgrades and gear improvements. Among the various scavenger hunts scattered throughout New Hanover and Ambarino, the High Stakes Treasure hunt stands out as an exceptionally rewarding line of discovery. Securing the initial document is the essential first step required to launch this lucrative sequence.

Finding the High Stakes Treasure Hunter

To obtain the first map, players must seek out a specific random encounter featuring an elderly treasure hunter roaming the wilderness. This non-playable character frequently spawns around prominent landmarks, particularly on the rocky cliffs between Diablo Ridge and Riggs Station. When you approach him, he will quickly attempt to conceal his discovery and ride away on horseback.

Acquiring the document requires swift action before the hunter escapes into the surrounding hills. Players can choose to hogtie or defeat the hunter to loot the map, though this action results in a minor loss of honor. Alternatively, running directly into him causes him to drop the item without triggering an honor penalty.

Deciphering the Clues on Map 1

Inspecting the first map reveals a distinct environmental sketch depicting a roaring waterfall flanked by heavy natural timber. This visual clue directly points players toward Cumberland Falls, located just west of Valentine along the Dakota River. Recognizing key geographical landmarks on these sketches makes navigating the frontier significantly smoother without unnecessary guesswork.

Reaching the falls is straightforward, but navigating the actual terrain requires careful footwork. Players must approach the riverbank near the base of the cascading waters to locate the hidden path. Staying alert to terrain hazards prevents accidental slips into the strong river currents.

Retrieving the Hidden Treasure at Cumberland Falls

Upon reaching Cumberland Falls, head toward the right side of the rushing water where a fallen log creates a natural bridge. Carefully walk along the log structure to step directly behind the heavy curtain of falling water. A shallow rock ledge hidden behind the spray allows Arthur to stand safely.

Tucked into a small crevice against the stone wall is the hidden nook holding your reward. Searching this precise spot yields $5 alongside the second map in the High Stakes chain. Collecting this next clue opens up the path toward the frozen reaches of the West Grizzlies.

Tips for Successful Exploration

Before embarking on any treasure hunt across the map, make sure your inventory is well-stocked with basic remedies and provisions. Keeping your stamina refreshed helps immensely when climbing steep rock faces or navigating wet riverbeds. Taking time to study each map carefully ensures you spend less time searching aimlessly.

If you happen to miss the stranger encounter multiple times, the game provides a helpful backup mechanism. The first map eventually becomes available for purchase at local Fence locations if the random encounter is avoided repeatedly. This ensures every player has the opportunity to complete the questline and claim all final gold rewards.